The Doctor Will See You Now. And Sell You a Serum.

UNFILTERED · Sarah Zimmer · Column 03

Medical school. Dermatology. Clinic. Instagram. One million followers. Serum.

There is a new career path in medicine.

It appears to go something like this.

Medical school. Dermatology. Clinic. Instagram. One million followers. Serum.

Apparently graduation now takes place at Sephora.

I noticed this because my Instagram feed has become increasingly concerned about my skin. There is always a doctor appearing to tell me that I am cleansing incorrectly, ageing incorrectly, applying vitamin C incorrectly or, most worryingly, buying somebody else's skincare incorrectly.

They are usually standing in a very beautiful clinic. Their skin is extraordinary. Behind them is something white, metallic or vaguely medical-looking. And beneath their name is the reassuring little prefix: Dr.

Beauty has always loved authority. Once it was the glamorous woman behind the cosmetics counter who apparently knew what my skin needed after looking at it for twelve seconds. Then came the celebrity. Then the facialist. Then the influencer.

Now we have reached the final boss.

The doctor.

And I understand why. If Brad Pitt launches a serum, I am entitled to wonder what Brad Pitt knows about epidermal biology. If a dermatologist launches one, that question feels almost rude.

Of course they understand skin. They went to medical school. Some have spent years treating acne, pigmentation, rosacea and skin disease. Some are genuinely brilliant physicians.

But somewhere in beauty's enthusiasm for credentials, we have quietly combined two completely different questions.

Does this person understand skin?

and

Is this an exceptional cosmetic formulation?

They are not the same question.

Diagnosing melanoma and formulating a moisturiser are both extremely difficult things. They are simply not the same difficult thing.

This should be obvious. And yet the entire visual language of modern skincare seems determined to make us forget it.

There is the white coat.

God, the white coat.

Can everybody please take the bloody lab coat off?

Doctors wear it. Chemists wear it. Founders stand next to people wearing it. Somebody holds a pipette. Somebody stares thoughtfully into a beaker. There is usually stainless steel somewhere in the background. Sometimes there is a molecule floating around for good measure.

SCIENCE IS HAPPENING.

I understand. You would like me to know that the serum wasn't mixed in a saucepan behind the till at Boots.

But at this point the entire beauty industry appears to be working the same shift at a pharmaceutical factory.

And it isn't just doctors. The chemist has become an influencer. The influencer has become a founder. The founder has become a skin educator. The dermatologist has become a content creator. The cosmetic doctor has become a retailer. Everyone has a podcast. Everyone is talking about longevity. Everyone has discovered inflammation.

And, eventually, everyone launches a serum.

I shouldn't laugh too loudly.

I trained as a nutritional therapist.

And then I launched supplements.

Groundbreaking.

Apparently none of us can resist eventually putting our qualifications into a bottle.

Perhaps I have simply not taken this far enough. Maybe I should acquire a suitably impressive doctorate.

Dr Sarah Zimmer.

It does have a certain ring to it.

I'll buy a white coat. We'll find me a laboratory. I can hold a pipette while looking deeply concerned about a beaker.

NAYA can become DOCTOR DEVELOPED overnight.

Perhaps we can add €40 to the moisturiser.

Will you buy more of it then?

Asking for a founder.

But the bit I find genuinely uncomfortable isn't the title.

It's the face.

Because the modern dermatologist doesn't merely provide medical authority. They frequently provide the before-and-after photograph as well.

Look at my skin. Here is what I recommend. Here is what I use. And increasingly: here is what I sell.

Except there is a fairly significant elephant sitting in the treatment room.

A cosmetic dermatologist has access to rather more than moisturiser.

Botox. Fillers. Lasers. Peels. Devices. Prescription treatments. Microneedling. Whatever terrifying machine has been invented since I started writing this paragraph.

And I have absolutely no objection to any of it. Do whatever you like with your forehead.

The problem is not intervention.
The problem is attribution.

If somebody has beautiful skin because they use excellent skincare, sunscreen, prescription treatments, Botox, laser treatments, a little filler, excellent genetics and a clinic full of dermatological equipment, wonderful.

But please don't stand next to a bottle of serum and allow my primitive monkey brain to conclude that the serum made the face.

It didn't. Or at least we have absolutely no idea how much of it did.

And this is where the whole doctor-skincare phenomenon becomes interesting. Because medicine has lent beauty something incredibly valuable.

Trust.

The title does some of the selling before we've even looked at the formula.

And social media has turbocharged it.

The dermatologist-to-skincare-brand pipeline is becoming remarkably efficient because the audience now arrives before the product does.

First you explain pigmentation. Then you debunk skincare myths. Then you tell us five things you would never do as a dermatologist. Then three things you would. Then you build a million followers.

And then, one Tuesday morning:

Good news. I made one.

Of course you did.

And perhaps it is excellent. That is important, because I'm not arguing that doctor-founded skincare is bad.

Some of it may be superb. Some doctors work with excellent cosmetic chemists and formulation laboratories. Some have spent years developing particular areas of expertise. Some products have proper finished-formula testing behind them.

But that still leaves the question I wish we'd ask more often:

If I removed the doctor's name from the bottle, would the formula still be interesting?

Take away the clinic. Take away Instagram. Take away the beautiful founder. Take away the white coat. Take away the million followers. Take away the story.

Now put the bottle on the table.

What have we actually got?

Because sometimes, underneath all that medical theatre, what we have is skincare technology the cosmetic industry has been using perfectly happily for years.

Beauty is particularly talented at discovering things it already knew.

Fermentation becomes exciting. Then boring. Then exciting again. Peptides disappear and return. Barrier repair becomes a revolution. Growth factors become a revolution. Longevity becomes a revolution.

Everything is revolutionary.

If skincare genuinely experienced as many revolutions as its marketing departments claim, the moisturiser would by now have overthrown the government.

And eventually even the doctor-founded brand encounters the same problem every skincare company encounters.

You made the hero product. People liked it. Excellent.

Now what?

Because a business cannot keep launching the same pigmentation serum forever. It needs growth.

So the pigmentation expert needs a moisturiser. Then something for redness. Then a cleanser. Then an eye product. Then perhaps a lip treatment because apparently lips have recently become an underserved medical emergency.

And suddenly the dermatologist who became famous telling us that skincare doesn't need to be complicated owns twelve products.

I find this funny.

I also find it painfully familiar.

Because NAYA is a business too.

We launch products. We advertise them. We need customers to buy them. We need revenue. And after you launch something successful, the question arrives remarkably quickly:

What's next?

So this isn't Sarah from NAYA pointing across the playground and laughing at everybody else's marketing.

I am standing in the playground.

I have products to sell.

I trained in nutrition and launched supplements, for God's sake.

I am exactly as predictable as everybody else.

Which is perhaps why this bothers me.

Because if we're all selling something, then credentials shouldn't get any of us out of having to prove that the something is good.

A dermatologist's expertise matters. A cosmetic chemist's expertise matters. A formulator's expertise matters. A toxicologist's expertise matters.

But none of those qualifications magically travels through the packaging and into the emulsion.

Your epidermis cannot read a CV.
It cannot see a white coat.
It doesn't know how many followers the founder has.

And it certainly doesn't give a shit whether I've finally managed to become Dr Sarah Zimmer, Molecular Something.

It gets the formula.

That's it.

So by all means tell me who developed my skincare. Tell me why they're qualified. Tell me what they know.

Then move them out of the way.

And show me what's in the bloody bottle.

Sarah Zimmer

Founder, NAYA · UNFILTERED